• Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Write For Us
  • Our Team
Extraction Magazine
No Result
View All Result
  • Botanical Extraction
    • Cannabinoids
    • Psychedelics
    • Nutraceutical
    • Product Refinement
  • Industry News
    • Business
    • Sustainability
    • Safety & Compliance
    • Partners
  • Extraction Technology
    • Equipment
    • Methods
    • Solvents
    • DIY Extraction
    • Analytical Techniques
  • Medical Research
  • Glossary
  • Business Directory
  • Botanical Extraction
    • Cannabinoids
    • Psychedelics
    • Nutraceutical
    • Product Refinement
  • Industry News
    • Business
    • Sustainability
    • Safety & Compliance
    • Partners
  • Extraction Technology
    • Equipment
    • Methods
    • Solvents
    • DIY Extraction
    • Analytical Techniques
  • Medical Research
  • Glossary
  • Business Directory
No Result
View All Result
Extraction Magazine
No Result
View All Result
Home Extraction Technology

Extraction Efficiencies for Butane, CO2, and Ethanol

Petar Petrov by Petar Petrov
August 23, 2019
in Extraction Technology, Solvents
Assorted cannabis oil containers with CBD, live resin and other thc extractions - medical marijuana concept

The efficiency of different cannabis extraction methods isn’t as straightforward as some people might think, and despite being measured with black-or-white math, it can also be somewhat individualistic.

In that spirit, here is how the main cannabis extraction methods — ethanol, hydrocarbon, and CO2 — compare against the main aspects of efficiency. Note: this article does not take into consideration other factors when deciding which technique is right for you, like end product, or overhead costs. We’re only discussing extraction efficiency here.

READ ALSO

What Is Winterization? Lessons From Food and Pharma for Extraction Operators

Solventless Extraction Methods Explained: What Food and Supplement Manufacturing Can Teach Operators

Throughput

This is perhaps the aspect that’s the closest to the traditional notion of efficiency. It basically refers to the size of the batch that can be processed at once and the speed at which a processing cycle is completed.

Quality of End Product

Quality refers to how closely the end product is to its intended, optimal state, or in other words, how much of the targeted cannabinoids are extracted and how much are left in the raffinate, or spent biomass.

In some cases, quality may be measured by THC (tetrahydrocannabinol) or CBD (cannabidiol) purity; in others, extractors may be after a rich, full-spectrum profile, with a specific color.

Extraction Methods

Ethanol Extraction

Ethanol extraction may be defined by the simplicity of a bulk method, but the final product’s purity is in the ballpark of 80% cannabinoids with a decent solvent recovery rate near 85%. Some extractors, like Capna provide equipment capable of processing 5.5 to 7.9 pounds of biomass in 30 or 40 minutes, respectively. The extraction efficiency of these systems is reported to be nearly 99%. Eden Labs offers a larger scale system that can process 74 pounds per hour with a listed efficiency ranging between 90 and 99%.

So, if higher-throughput is indispensable, but supreme purity isn’t and, instead, decent results in that regard are sufficient, ethanol extraction can be attractive.

Supercritical CO2 Extraction

Supercritical carbon dioxide (CO2) extraction is efficient in terms of the precision of targeting different cannabinoids, and especially terpenes, as it’s a non-polar solvent, and extraction temperature and pressure are adjustable. This is why this method is popular among extractors who are after terpenes and aromatic end products.

One small-scale CO2 extraction study reported an extraction efficiency of 92%. [1] Larger scale, commercial CO2 extractors, like those at Apeks Supercritical, are capable of reaching this level of efficiency as well.

Supercritical extraction is sometimes labeled as not being super-fast compared to hydrocarbon extraction. For example, Claywolf found it produces 3 production runs with CO2 in 24 hours, the same time it takes its sister company to produce 18 with hydrocarbon.

The capacity of the CO2 extraction vessel, however, controls how much biomass can be processed in a given time. The 2x360L system available from Thar Process, for example, can extract 2,000 to 3,000 pounds of biomass per 24 hours, using 3 production shifts, and Thar manufacturers the largest CO2 extraction vessels in the world, which can greatly augment processing throughput.

Solvent recovery is more efficient with CO2 compared to ethanol, as nearly 99.9% of the CO2 can be recycled, without concomitant losses in the recirculated solvent’s ability to adequately solvate the molecules of interest.

Hydrocarbon Extraction

Hydrocarbon extraction involves solvents like butane or propane, which, like CO2, are non-polar, so they are also great if you’re targeting fat-soluble THC, CBD, and terpenes. Since these are ubiquitously considered the current Holy Trinity of cannabis, hydrocarbon extraction, despite its obvious safety concerns, is still a relevant method for product design. When compared to CO2, however, longer contact times can remove undesirable compounds like chlorophyll.

Claywolf praises the energy efficiency offered by hydrocarbon extraction in terms of electricity usage, as well as its speed, demonstrating processing capacities of 15 pounds per hour and others going through 18 production runs in 24 hours. ExtractionTek provides higher-throughput options that are capable of reaching 55 or 100 pounds per 8-hour shift, for butane and propane, respectively, and Precision Extraction Solutions manufactures more industrial-scale systems that can process 3,000 pounds per day using 3 shifts.

Solvent recovery is possible with hydrocarbon extraction, with a reasonable recovery of around 90%. While higher efficiencies are reachable, input energy requirements can hinder what’s practical.

Hydrocarbon extraction is labeled by some to be the most efficient, but it’s clear that the efficiencies of ethanol and CO2 can also be quite high. As mentioned above, efficiency is a multi-faceted matter and can be determined on the individual extractor’s needs and goals. This article highlighted some efficiencies regarding extraction solvent, biomass throughput, and solvent recovery. Other factors will be important, however, including solvent storage capabilities, since there are restrictions on storing large quantities of potentially dangerous solvents; waste generation; and capital costs for obtaining the desired equipment.

References: 

[1] Rovetto, L. and Aieta, N. “Supercritical carbon dioxide extraction of cannabinoids from Cannabis sativa L. plant material”, The Journal of Supercritical Fluids, vol. 129, 2017, pp. 16-27. [journal impact factor = 3.481; cited by 9]

Related Posts

Botanical Extraction

What Is Winterization? Lessons From Food and Pharma for Extraction Operators

November 21, 2026
Botanical Extraction

Solventless Extraction Methods Explained: What Food and Supplement Manufacturing Can Teach Operators

November 18, 2026
Botanical Extraction

What Is Steam Distillation? Lessons From Food, Pharma and Supplements for Extraction Operators

November 15, 2026
Equipment

Fractional Distillation vs Short Path Distillation: What Pharma and Food Plants Can Teach Extraction Operators

November 11, 2026
Botanical Extraction

Hydrosol vs Essential Oil: Which Product Stream Should Your Facility Be Built Around?

November 9, 2026
Botanical Extraction

Clean Rooms, Air Handling and Environmental Controls: What Extraction Operators Can Learn from Food and Pharma

November 3, 2026
Next Post
Methods for Extraction Oil Refinement, Part 1

Methods for Extraction Oil Refinement, Part 1

Sitemap

© 2026 Extraction Magazine is the trusted provider of botanical extraction news and the leading media in the ever-changing extraction industry.

No Result
View All Result
  • Industry News
  • Botanical Extraction
  • Medical Research
  • Medical Research
  • Glossary
  • Our Team
  • Write For Us

© 2026 Extraction Magazine is the trusted provider of botanical extraction news and the leading media in the ever-changing extraction industry.